This Forbidden Thing Called Love
Book Nook / Contemporary Indian Fiction · Romance
Contemporary Indian Fiction · Romance
This Forbidden Thing Called Love
Bubbles Sabharwal
The Browser
"Our choices inevitably leave scars on the people who have to clean up after us."
★★★½☆
Reviewed by Sayantika Chakraborty
"What we inherit is not love itself, but its unfinished consequences."
We readers must have all at some point of our "reading-life" encountered the classic (or cliché) literary setup: a daughter stumbles upon a dusty box of old letters. She suddenly realizes her parents actually had personalities, desires, and an emotional life before she arrived to disrupt it. In Bubbles Sabharwal's latest, This Forbidden Thing Called Love, this discovery plunges us straight into the messy reality of Arjun and Shivani.

On the surface, it might look like another standard, slow-burning romance; the kind where you expect two hundred pages of stolen glances and romantic encounters yearning for lost love, and a neat, satisfying "and they lived happily ever after" resolution.

Except, this isn't the book where you actually get it.

Instead of staying firmly glued to our main protagonists, the narrative frequently shifts focus. It hands the storytelling duties to its most powerful strength — an entire ensemble cast. From judgmental extended family members to the fiercely loyal domestic staff, and even the family pets who are forced to witness the high-stakes family drama. If you are paying attention, the plot is somewhat predictable: we all know that defying heavy societal norms rarely ends with everyone smiling. Furthermore, Sabharwal's writing — which is undeniably rich and operating at an elevated literary level — suffers from a minor addiction to repetition, reusing a few chosen, poignant words a bit too often as if to ensure the reader doesn't miss the tragedy.

Yet, the character development of Arjun and Shivani thrives precisely because of this fractured structure. We don't just watch them love each other, we watch their community react to them, giving their relationship a layered, realistic depth. They evolve from fiercely devoted idealists into heavily scarred individuals, entirely shaped by the unforgiving environment they inhabit. Admittedly, the book occasionally trips over its own desire to comfort the reader. A few subplots and family feuds wrap up a bit too neatly, offering tidy resolutions before the narrative has truly earned them. If you prefer your relationship drama to remain messy and unresolved, these convenient exits might make you roll your eyes just a little.

Ultimately, the novel succeeds because it zeroes in on a painful, unglamorous truth: our choices inevitably leave scars on the people who have to clean up after us. It leaves you feeling entirely drained, staring blankly at the wall while mourning a fictional couple you wish had just lived, enjoyed, and forgiven a little more.

"What survives longer — love itself, or the consequences of loving?"

← Back to Book Nook